Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg appears on a monitor as he testifies remotely during the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington on Oct. 28, 2020.POOL/Reuters
The U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee on Thursday approved a bill that would bar tech giants like Amazon AMZN-Q from giving preference to their own businesses on their websites, despite hefty lobbying from top executives like Apple Chief Executive Tim Cook.
The biggest technology companies, including Meta Platforms Inc’s Facebook FB-Q and Apple Inc AAPL-Q, have been under pressure in Congress because of allegations they abused their outsized market power. A long list of bills is aimed at reining them in, but none have become law.
Lawmakers voted on an amended version of a bill introduced by Senators Amy Klobuchar, a Democrat, and Chuck Grassley, a Republican, that expanded the definition of companies covered by the bill to include firms like the popular video app TikTok and specified that companies were not required to share data with firms that the U.S. government considers national security risks.
EU Parliament agrees on proposal to take on U.S. tech giants
Republican Senator Ted Cruz said during the hearing that he spoke on Wednesday with Cook, saying he “expressed significant concerns about the bill.”
Cruz, who voted for the measure, said Cook expressed a “reasonable” concern the bill would make it harder for Apple to allow consumers to protect their privacy by electing that apps not be allowed to monitor or track their online activities.
Klobuchar, chair of the panel’s antitrust panel, said after the vote that she also had spoken with both Cook and Google CEO Sundar Pichai.
“I had discussions with them and I made my case and I listened to them. They are most likely never going to like this bill,” she said adding that she was open to changes but not to gutting the measure. “We’re not going to put a bill forward that does nothing.”
The Cowen Washington Research Group said that despite the committee’s 16-6 vote to approve the measure, enough of its supporters expressed reservations that it had less than a 50% chance of becoming law.
A second bill, which was held over, would bar big app stores, like Apple’s, from requiring app providers to use their payment system and prohibit them from punishing apps that offer different prices through another app store or payment system.
Both bills have a version in the U.S. House of Representatives.
The legislation aimed at Big Tech set off a firestorm of opposition from powerful business groups.
Matt Schruers, president of the Computer and Communications Industry Association, criticized the Klobuchar/Grassley measure and predicted it would not pass the Senate. “Antitrust policy should aim to promote consumer welfare - not punish specific companies,” he said in a statement.
The advocacy group Consumer Reports supported the Klobuchar/Grassley bill to “reset the power asymmetry between Big Tech, consumers and small businesses.”
Be smart with your money. Get the latest investing insights delivered right to your inbox three times a week, with the Globe Investor newsletter. Sign up today.